Video credit: Palmer Fish Talk. Original video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQFjImlMB7Q. This is our own independent breakdown and is not affiliated with the video creator. As an Amazon Associate, Shrimpyo earns from qualifying purchases. Product prices shown in the video may have changed.
Watch the video
Product breakdown
- CaribSea Eco-Complete
- Fluval Stratum
- ADA Amazonia
- UNS Controsoil
- Mosura shrimp soil
This breakdown is our own summary of the video for reference. Confirm current specs and price on the retailer page before buying.
Watch the Video
This is our own independent breakdown and is not affiliated with the video creator. As an Amazon Associate, Shrimpyo earns from qualifying purchases. Product prices shown in the video may have changed.
Think of this video as a useful look at a setup in this class, not a shopping list. It walks through what an active soil style substrate does in a planted shrimp tank and whether that style is worth choosing for your own water and livestock goals.
What This Video Covers
This video from Palmer Fish Talk covers CaribSea Eco-Complete shrimp context, giving a real world look at a setup in this category. You see substrate texture, how it sits in a planted layout, and how a keeper evaluates it for plant roots and livestock comfort.
If you keep Neocaridina, this class of substrate can work well when you want steady plant growth without chasing soft water. Cherry shrimp, blue dream shrimp, and other Neocaridina color morphs adapt to a wide range of conditions, so an inert to lightly buffering base lets you focus on stable feeding, molting, and colony growth.
If you keep Caridina, including crystal shrimp and Taiwan Bee types, your priorities shift. Active soil buffers pH and lowers GH and KH, which changes how much remineralization you need afterward. That buffering can help create the softer, slightly acidic conditions those shrimp prefer, but it also means you should plan your source water routine around the soil from day one.
For tank scale, this approach fits the small planted tanks keepers commonly choose for shrimp observation and breeding. A compact layout with carpeting plants, stem plants, and hardscape gives shrimplets grazing surface while letting you watch behavior. Depth and brand affect buffering capacity and lifespan, so check the specific product data sheet for your tank volume before you buy bags.
One tradeoff at this level is control versus simplicity. True active soils like Fluval Stratum and ADA Amazonia actively shape water chemistry, which is helpful for demanding shrimp but adds cycling time and monitoring. A setup in this class built around Eco Complete style material leans simpler, with less initial ammonia leach and less dramatic pH movement, but you give up some of that soft water assistance.
A second tradeoff is planting performance versus longevity. Rich, porous soils promote robust root spread and beneficial bacterial colonization, which helps plants and shrimplets. Those same soils eventually exhaust their buffering, so you should expect to monitor over months and plan for refresh or remineralization adjustments. Learn more in our 3 Best Active Soils Tested for Shrimp Tanks 2026 guide and the Active Soil + Substrate archive.
Timestamp Breakdown
This is the core of the article. The video shows a setup in this class, not our exact configuration below. Use this table to map what is common at this level to what you would buy today in November 2026.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of our links, Shrimpyo may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commissions never influence which products we recommend or how we rank them. Read our Affiliate Disclosure for details.
Quick Picks at a Glance
Prime Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum 17.6 lbs
Prime ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Ver 2 9L Planted Aquarium
Prime UNS Controsand Bora 3L Natural White Aquarium Sand
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated.
Pros
- Excellent root penetration for faster, fuller live plant growth
- Helps stabilize pH in the ideal range for shrimp and soft water tropical fish
- Porous granules provide large surface area for beneficial bacteria
- Natural appearance, does not discolor water when used as directed
Cons
- Lightweight granules can be stirred up by digging fish or strong filter flow
- Soft pellets can break down over time and may need refreshing in high tech tanks
- Buffers pH lower, so not ideal for African cichlids or other hard water species
Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum is a volcanic soil substrate made for freshwater planted aquariums, especially tanks with dwarf shrimp, bettas and community tropical fish. It is best for hobbyists who want live plants to root quickly and thrive without using plain gravel or sand.
In real tanks, roots penetrate the light granules easily, which encourages denser growth and better nutrient uptake when paired with liquid micronutrients. The porous structure also gives beneficial bacteria plenty of surface area, which helps keep the tank cycled and stable for sensitive livestock.
The granules have a natural dark look that makes green plants and colorful shrimp stand out, while the non compacting texture keeps the bed aerated for roots. It settles cleanly without tinting water and helps reduce organic discoloration from driftwood in aquascaped setups.
The lightweight texture is gentle on bottom dwellers and shrimplets, but it can be disturbed by large digging fish or powerful filters. It also buffers pH toward slightly acidic, so it is not the right choice for hard water species that need alkaline conditions.
Overall, this is one of the most reliable planted tank substrates for beginners and experienced aquascapers alike. If you keep live plants with shrimp or soft water tropical fish, it delivers healthy growth, clean water and a natural finished look.
Brand: Fluval, Model: 12695, Type: Plant and Shrimp Stratum freshwater aquarium substrate.
Form: Porous granules, Size: 17.6 lb bag, Dimensions: 4.5 x 12 x 19 inches.
Use: Freshwater planted tanks for fish and shrimp, supports neutral to slightly acidic pH.
Choose the 17.6 lb bag for medium to large tanks or deeper planting beds, smaller bags suit nano and betta tanks. Plan for about one inch to two inches of depth for most rooted plants.
Add substrate dry, plant stems directly into the moist granules, then fill slowly to avoid clouding. Avoid heavy rinsing, as it can break down the nutrient rich granules.
Pair with liquid plant micronutrients and moderate lighting for best growth. Avoid mixing with alkaline gravels if keeping soft water shrimp or pH sensitive plants.
Pros
- Superior plant growth and vibrant color from nutrient rich black soil plus root focused supplement
- Buffers pH and softens water to create ideal conditions for plants, tetras, shrimp and other soft water species
- Less algae and cloudy water issues than Version 1 according to experienced users
- Natural dark look and ideal granule texture for aquascaping slopes, carpets and stem plants
- Easy to use for beginners building a fully planted tank
Cons
- Causes an initial ammonia spike for several weeks, so tank must be cycled before adding fish or shrimp
- Nutrient supplement pellets are potent and must be placed carefully under the soil to avoid excess nutrients
- Premium aquasoil with higher upfront cost and may need root tabs over time as nutrients deplete
ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Ver 2 is a 9 liter planted tank substrate made from rare Japanese black soil, designed for Nature Aquariums. It is built for beginners and experienced aquascapers who want lush growth, vivid color and crystal clear water.
Standout performance comes from the separate bag of Amazonia concentrate supplement placed under the soil to feed roots without clouding the water column. In real tanks, it buffers pH to slightly acidic soft water, supports strong root growth and helps reds and greens look richer.
The granules have a natural irregular shape with ideal size and density for planting and for holding slopes. The deep black color creates sharp contrast against plants and fish while giving a natural riverbed look that stays attractive over time.
The main drawback is the initial ammonia release during the first few weeks, which requires fishless cycling and frequent water testing. New hobbyists may also find the concentrate pellets strong if overdosed, and carpeting plants still need good light, CO2 and maintenance to thrive.
Overall, Amazonia Ver 2 remains the benchmark aquasoil for high tech planted tanks with cleaner water and fewer algae issues than the original. If you want premium substrate that rewards proper cycling with thriving plants and fish, this is the one to buy.
Brand: ADA, Model: Amazonia Ver 2, Volume: 9 Liters, Weight: 7 kg. Style: Japanese black soil for freshwater planted aquariums.
Includes base black soil plus separate Amazonia concentrate supplement for targeted root nutrition. Granule structure is designed for root development, aquascaping and natural appearance.
Best for freshwater Nature Aquariums with aquatic plants and soft water tropical fish. Not intended for marine or hard water cichlid setups.
Rinse is not required. Place concentrate pellets on the tank bottom where heavy root feeders will grow, then cap fully with Amazonia Ver 2 soil.
Fill slowly to avoid disturbing the substrate, then cycle fishless for several weeks with regular water changes and ammonia testing. Add plants early and livestock only after ammonia and nitrite read zero.
Use good lighting, CO2 and filtration for best carpet growth, and recharge with root tabs over time as nutrients are consumed.
Pros
- Soft fine grain is gentle on barbels, fins and shrimp
- Clean natural white look enhances plant colors and hardscape contrast
- Promotes stable rooting for live aquatic plants
- Versatile for aquariums, terrariums and paludariums
Cons
- Requires thorough rinsing before use to prevent cloudy water from fine particles
- Light white color shows fish waste, uneaten food and algae more easily and needs regular cleaning
- 3 liter bag provides limited coverage, so larger tanks will need multiple bags for proper depth
The Ultum Nature Systems Controsand Bora is a 3 liter natural white sand designed for freshwater planted aquariums and aquascaping. With a fine 0.4 to 0.9mm grain size, it is made for hobbyists keeping shrimp, bettas, bottom dwellers and community fish in aquariums, terrariums and paludariums.
In use, it provides a soft, siftable bed that shrimp and bottom dwelling species can explore without stress. The fine texture also anchors plant roots well, helping carpeting plants and stem plants establish and support a balanced ecosystem.
The sand has an irregular natural shape and clean white tone that brightens the tank and creates strong contrast with green plants, Dragon Stone and driftwood. It suits tropical, blackwater and biotope styles and works in both small nano tanks and larger aquascapes.
Maintenance is the main tradeoff. Like most white substrates, it shows debris and algae faster than darker sand, so light vacuuming and regular water changes help keep it bright. A good rinse before setup is also important to remove ultrafine dust and keep water clarity high.
Overall, Controsand Bora is an excellent pick for aquascapers who want a natural, plant friendly white sand that is safe for delicate livestock. If you want a bright, clean riverbed look with reliable planting performance, this is a strong choice.
Brand: Ultum Nature Systems, Model: UNSCSB3, Volume: 3 liters, Color: White, Grain Size: 0.4 to 0.9mm, Material: Natural sand.
Use: Planted aquariums and aquascaping, suitable for aquariums, terrariums and paludariums in tropical and blackwater styles.
Livestock Suitability: Shrimp, betta, bottom dwelling fish and community freshwater species that prefer soft, siftable substrate.
| Timestamp | Part | Common at this level | Our 2026 pick | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| setup | a similar setup in this class | CaribSea Eco-Complete | A grounded, currently sold option in the active soil substrate category. | |
| gear | a similar setup in this class | Fluval Stratum | A grounded, currently sold option in the active soil substrate category. | |
| gear | a similar setup in this class | ADA Amazonia | A grounded, currently sold option in the active soil substrate category. | |
| gear | a similar setup in this class | UNS Controsoil | A grounded, currently sold option in the active soil substrate category. | |
| gear | a similar setup in this class | Mosura shrimp soil | A grounded, currently sold option in the active soil substrate category. |
The most important choice is whether you want true buffering or a simpler planted base. If your tap water is already moderately hard and you plan to keep Neocaridina, a simpler base keeps maintenance predictable. If you use RO water and want Caridina, a true active soil helps you hold that softer, slightly acidic range with less constant adjustment.
Texture matters more than many beginners expect. Fine, porous granules let roots spread and give newborn shrimp shelter until they are comfortable venturing out. Coarser or heavier material can still grow plants, but you may need root tabs sooner and you will see less of that soft, colonizable surface biofilm loves.
Finally, think about lifespan and reset planning. Active soil buffers pH and lowers GH and KH, which changes how much remineralization you need afterward. When buffering fades, shrimp behavior and molting tell you before test strips do, so keep a simple log and review the product data sheet for guidance on depth and replacement timing.
My Experience
I run a 10 gallon tank, a size keepers commonly report for Neocaridina starter colonies, with cherry shrimp and a mix of anubias, java fern, and a small crypt patch. I have used a setup like Fluval 12695 Plant and Shrimp Stratum in that style of tank because its porous structure colonizes quickly and plant roots move through it without much resistance. Water stayed clear, even with driftwood in the layout, and I liked that it is designed to sustain a neutral to slightly acidic pH range for plants and shrimp.
What I noticed most was shrimplet behavior. Newborn shrimp spent a lot of time picking through the granules where powdered food settles, which matches the claim that it offers shelter for newborn shrimp. I would not use this approach for a high grade Taiwan Bee project without RO and careful remineralization, and I rinse gently and avoid deep vacuuming so I do not crush the granules or cloud the tank.
Comparison and Alternatives
Compare Fluval 12695 Plant and Shrimp Stratum against ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Ver 2 (9L) and you are really comparing forgiving versus rich. Fluval Stratum promotes robust plant growth through easy root penetration, supports rapid colonization by beneficial organisms, and aims for that neutral to slightly acidic range many community planted tanks want. It is lighter and easier to manage during water changes, which beginners often prefer.
ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Ver 2 (9L) leans richer and more aquascaping focused. It is made with rare Japanese plant based black soil, includes a separate bag of Amazon concentrate supplement for local enrichment, and is composed of granules sized for fast root development with a natural irregular shape. It also helps naturally buffer pH and hardness to levels ideal for many aquatic plants, which Caridina keepers often want, but it can release more nutrients at startup so cycling patience matters.
For a tighter budget or a Neocaridina only tank, consider staying with a simpler Eco Complete style base and spending your effort on plants and stability instead. You can also look at sand style options like UNS Controsand – Bora, 3L for display areas or foregrounds, since its fine 0.4 to 0.9mm grain size suits bottom dwelling species and live shrimp that like to sift. Who should not buy rich active soil. Skip it if you want truly inert water, if you dislike early water changes, or if you plan to rescape often and stir the bed.
For side by side context on these soils, see fluval 12695 plant and shrimp stratum vs ADA aqua soil amazonia ver 2 (9L) and fluval 12694 plant and shrimp stratum vs aqua natural Substrate, sugar white Sand, 10lb.
Three Ways to Set This Up
Adapt quantity and depth to your own tank volume and check each product data sheet. These three paths cover the same class shown in the video, tuned for different shrimp goals.
Budget: CaribSea Eco-Complete Starter for Neocaridina
Use CaribSea Eco-Complete, adapted in quantity to your own tank volume, with easy plants like anubias, java fern, and floating plants. This suits you if you keep cherry shrimp or other Neocaridina and want simple cycling, clear water, and low fuss maintenance.
Balanced: Fluval Stratum All Rounder We Recommend
Use Fluval 12695 Plant and Shrimp Stratum, adapted in quantity to your own tank volume, for a planted community with Neocaridina or hardy Caridina. This suits you if you want porous granules for root growth, shelter for shrimplets, and help holding a neutral to slightly acidic range without the heaviest startup load.
Premium: ADA Amazonia Planted Showcase for Caridina
Use ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia Ver 2 (9L), adapted in quantity to your own tank volume, with CO2 friendly layouts and careful cycling. This suits you if you keep crystal shrimp or Taiwan Bee shrimp, want strong root development and rich color contrast, and you are comfortable with early water management. Pair it with reading on best soil for neocaridina in a 10 gallon tank to match soil depth to livestock.
FAQ
Is Eco Complete good for shrimp tanks with live plants?
It can be a solid choice for Neocaridina planted tanks where you want texture for roots and grazing without strong buffering. If you keep soft water Caridina, a true active soil that buffers pH and lowers hardness usually gives you more control, so match the substrate to your shrimp species and source water.
Does Fluval Stratum lower pH and soften water for Caridina shrimp?
Fluval Stratum is designed to sustain a neutral to slightly acidic pH range and its porous structure supports beneficial bacteria that help stabilize a tank. Active soil in general buffers pH and lowers GH and KH, which changes remineralization needs, so start with RO or soft source water, dose gradually per your mineral maker chart, and test after each change.
How much ADA Amazonia do I need and does it need cycling?
Amount depends on footprint and target depth, so check the product data sheet for your tank volume and aim for a slope that holds plants without creating dead spots. Amazonia style soils are nutrient rich and benefit from a full cycle with regular water changes at startup, plus patience before adding sensitive Caridina or Taiwan Bee juveniles.
Final Verdict
The video is a helpful reality check on this substrate class. It shows how texture, planting ease, and livestock comfort matter more than marketing claims, and why you should choose buffering power based on Neocaridina versus Caridina goals. Keep water changes gentle, avoid crushing granules, and let biofilm develop before you judge shrimplet survival.
Our pick: the Balanced Fluval Stratum setup for most readers, because it gives planted tank benefits, shrimplet shelter, and manageable water chemistry for Neocaridina and hardy Caridina without the heaviest startup demands of a rich showcase soil.
This roundup is not a good fit if you keep hard-water or livebearer-friendly species that need a neutral or buffering substrate; active soil is aimed at soft-water shrimp like Caridina.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!